(In my latest Economic Times column, a quirky combining of thoughts on two recent films)
-------------------------------------------
“They know the facts. The story has yet to be told” – from Alejandro Gonzalez Inarritu’s Digger
With my eccentric knack for linking unrelated films, I have been thinking about two recent favourites, Inarritu’s Digger and Balaji Tharaneetharan’s Baththa. Specifically, about the use of doors and proscenium arches in these movies: as portals, as rites of passage, or as cues to artifice.
In scale, plot and tone, these two works are very different. The first is an enormously ambitious big-picture film about the impending end of the world – brought about by human greed and climate change – and our collective complicity and blindness (even when we conscientiously watch films and read books on the subject, and congratulate ourselves on being Aware). The second is an intimate tale set in 1980s Madras, about a little boy and a local thug who “meet”, in unusual circumstances, on opposite sides of a closed door.
Digger, a flop that may slowly be developing a cult following, opens with a series of delicate watery vistas, and the parting of an ornate curtain. We are in the room of the titular oil tycoon – played by Tom Cruise – who is sitting up in bed, about to learn that he has caused an ecological disaster. With hindsight, this elegant frame can be seen as the film telegraphing its secret (I’ll disclose it here since it is revealed only thirty minutes into the narrative, and it isn’t possible to discuss Digger without it): we aren’t watching the “real” Digger Rockwell but an actor involved in the dramatization of real-life events that took place 20 years earlier. The play being staged – “Fossil Fools”, it is called! – is the story that organises the messy facts into a digestible narrative. (Is it also a play that can catch the conscience of a complacent viewer? Well, that’s another matter altogether.)
To learn this means to realise that almost everything we see in the film is performative and self-reflexive – from actors playing caricatured evil (or bumbling) men to regular people enacting virtuousness. Or a future audience watching a beautiful natural world that no longer exists for them.
Coming to Baththa: performance is also central – in a smaller-canvas way – to this story about transitions and rites of passage. A central event here is a young girl’s puberty ceremony, which her parents are preparing for. But a bigger epiphany awaits this girl’s father, a hoodlum named Baththa, who accidentally gets locked in a school toilet during the holiday season. A little boy, Sabari, silently keeps Baththa alive by pushing crushed rusk under the door for several days, but he is afraid to unlock the door or to reveal his identity, being terrified by the man’s reputation.
Thus both films in different ways deal with narrative-construction, and a presented version of self. From the start we see Baththa through the eyes of the awestruck child who has heard legends about his invincibility (he can break out of any prison! He has a pet lion! They pee together on the electrical transformer, causing power outages!) – it is only later that we see the more mundane, and eventually the childlike and vulnerable, aspects of the man.
Without giving too much away: the closed school turns out to be a place where Baththa goes to perform something that in his regular social environment he can no longer comfortably do – because he has so thoroughly set himself in the mould of a tough guy. By contrast, in Digger, the floundering pre-release marketing at one point implied that the protagonist was a gung-ho saviour (in the vein of Tom Cruise characters in action films). But in the bleak and uncomforting film that arrived in our theatres, Digger Rockwell is nearly irrelevant, and his end is ignominious.
“The door is open.” Those are the words we see – scrawled on a piece of paper – in Baththa’s closing shot. (The film’s clever opening-credits scene had shown us the bathroom door being built and installed.) Doors also open in the last scene of Digger – the doors of a theatrical space, so that the play’s audience can exit. This builds up to a stunning look at the dystopia outside the theatre. Which becomes (or can become) a portal to fearful understanding for us, the viewers watching Digger.
I thought about that great closing scene again a few days ago when I got up at 4 AM the morning after Diwali in Delhi and mulled on what the toxic air must be doing to my insides. At such times, of course, all doors (and windows) are best kept shut.
-----------------
P.S. further scattered thoughts on Digger, which I watched twice in the hall (the first time on IMAX, which was definitely the better experience).
I was mostly captivated by the film, even as I felt a smidgen of sympathy for viewers who had been perplexed or infuriated, or just thought it was very laboured in places. Tom Cruise was excellent, and I loved the sound and art design, including the marvelous end-credits sequence, which reminded me of the “Where Have All the Flowers Gone” montage at the end of Yorgos Lanthimos’s Bugonia. And it was such an effective touch to have a booming, non-diegetic “Level 4” announcement a short while into those end-credits, as if it were directed at us, the viewers watching this film. (You need to see the film to appreciate the effect of this.) It was the sort of nasty, complacent-audience-implicating 4th Wall-breaker that has had a rich tradition in political theatre over the centuries.
I do, sort of, understand some of the negative criticisms (I mean the ones that are a little more thought-out and engaged than just “Everyone is shouting and over-acting, the humour is too loud”). I believe there is a concern about this being, or appearing to be, a preachy scold of a film. Which it might be to a degree, depending on what your lens is – but some pedantry may also be unavoidable for a work that deals head-on with no less a subject than the fast-arriving end of the world and our species’s culpability in it. That said, I think the most seemingly preachy or heavy scenes – e.g. Digger’s much-discussed 10-minute monologue, or the outburst in the plane by Riz Ahmed’s Dr Ganesh – should be viewed as red herrings; given the self-reflexive *and* self-contradicting nature of this narrative, one doesn’t have to see those scenes as being the film’s intended takeaway, or as its final “position” on the subject of climate change. Much of the point is that we don’t actually know anything about the ”real” Digger or the other people being depicted, or exactly what happened, or how many different degrees and layers of culpability exist.
One piece I saw on Instagram made the important point that the audience we see at the end of the film are the elites of this dystopian future world – the very small percentage of people who can afford to go for art-therapy of this sort, and can also afford those oxygen masks, which most people outside the theatre don’t seem to have. With this in mind, it’s easier to see the parallels with greedy zombie consumers of OTT “content” such as ourselves (this includes binging on the virtuous, conscience-awakening films that some of us take special pleasure in, and which allow us to hold on to the delusion that things aren’t all that bad. Or that our self-awareness means something tangible).
No comments:
Post a Comment